Fair share of Carbon Space in Atmosphere



Carbon space refers to the space in the atmosphere to absorb carbon dioxide.
The atmosphere has little space left to absorb more carbon dioxide, and developing countries are now claiming their fair share to what remains. Therefore, a global deal on climate change must put fairness and equity at the center of its design, taking into account that much of the carbon dioxide and other dangerous gases in the atmosphere have been placed thereby developed countries.
The deal must ensure that developing countries be given "carbon space" and "development space" to survive a well as to achieve their development goals. Without such a design, developing Countries will suffer from both a climate and a development Crisis. While developed countries will continue to occupy most of the "carbon space".
The "carbon equity" principle was most prominently stressed by the former Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh. He said any agreement on climate was not acceptable to developing countries if it was not anchored in equity and an equitable sharing of atmospheric space among all countries which should not remain as mere words but must be given operational effect.

Amount of Carbon Emission:
The scientists estimate that about 1,200 Giga-tones (Gtons) of CO2 equivalents have been emitted from 1850 to 2009. (1Giga = 1 billion),
Of this, about 400 Gtons was emitted during 1850-1970 and 800 Gtons during 1970-2009. To have a half-chance of limiting the rise in global temperature to 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels, another 1,000 Gtons can be emitted for the years 2010–50.

Actual V/s Fair Share of Carbon Space:



      The United States with 5% of the world's population in 2009 has contributed 29% of the increase in carbon in the atmosphere in 1850-2009, thus exceeding its fair share of carbon space by 24%, according to the paper's data.

      Other developed countries with 14% of world population contributed 45%.
      The developing countries overall had 81% of world population and its fair share of the total emissions of 1850–2009 is thus also 81%. But in fact their share of actual emissions was only 26%. They have thus under-used their share by 55%.

      Almost all the developing countries have "under-used" what would have been their share of the carbon space. India with 17% of world population has a 3% contribution to total emissions of 1850-2009, and China (so often blamed by the West) has 20% of world population and a 10% share of total historical emissions.

The following aspects to be noted in respect of fair share of carbon space:

1. Climate Change and Rights:
      It is clear that if global warming continues at the current rate, civilization as we know will probably end, perhaps not with a whimper but a bang.

      Even if partially mitigated, is going to affect millions of people.

      The human rights framework must be used not only to identify what rights people have that are or will be violated but also people/countries/groups that violate such rights.
       
2. Locating the Problem:
      The key issue what action is leading to violation of people’s rights to life and stable environment?
      It is clearly the over-use of the global commons by some groups or countries.
      If carbon dioxide emissions are not cut, global warming is inevitable.


3. Kyoto Response (United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) 1997 at Kyoto in Japan.
      Kyoto recognized this in its formulation of "common but differentiated responsibility".

      Common because we are dealing with the global commons

      Differentiated because up to that historical point, some countries have used disproportionate share of the existing carbon space.

      Also recognized "carbon space" is also development Space developing countries had primary objective of poverty reduction.
4. Introducing Carbon Budget: Carbon budgeting" refers to determining how much various countries contributed through the years to the carbon in the atmosphere, how much more carbon can the atmosphere absorb before there are disastrous consequences to the Earth, and how this remaining "carbon space" should be allocated among various countries.

      If we want to limit temperature rise to 2 Degree C (or a lower value) we need to put numbers of aggregate future emissions that will allow us to stay within this limit.

      Nature papers last year made clear that the best way of looking at it is to look at total aggregate carbon emissions from now to 2050.

      The window of keeping temperature rise within 2 Degree C is only 2010-2050.


5. Rules for Allocating Carbon Space:
      Countries cut "consumption emissions" if current share is more than fair share of carbon space.

      Countries with per capita emissions above specified thresholds implement steeper cut if global budget exceeded.

      Countries are allowed "development" emissions if current share less than the fair share of carbon space subject to global carbon budget.

6. Impact on Developing Countries:

      If developed countries cut slowly carbon emission, less carbon space will be left for the developing countries.

      If carbon space is limited, developing countries will be affected.

      Incur higher cost per unit of energy to lower emissions.


Previous
Next Post »